OP-ED: Sure, pass design-build. But don’t stop there.
What’s being portrayed as a panacea for project delivery is just one option New York should provide
By Kirk Narburgh, AIA, and Georgi Ann Bailey, Hon. AIANYS
New York state is dealing with the deteriorating condition of our public spaces, places and transportation infrastructure. Unfortunately, our approach to these challenges is often reactive and confined to a single solution, which leaves us scrambling to fix the problems of yesterday instead of formulating a comprehensive plan to address the challenges of tomorrow.
The recently enacted state budget authorized the use of a project-delivery method known as design-build for several important projects in New York City which have been languishing. The prospect of design-build has seemingly breathed new life into these projects, but it has not set forth an overall strategy to reform the procurement, delivery and management of public projects.
Project delivery should never be confined to a single option, and the benefits and challenges of design-build should not be evaluated in a vacuum. Design-build combines design and construction services under a single contract in order to condense the procurement process and merge the delivery strategy. However, it is just one of a larger universe of project delivery methods with the capability to reduce project schedules, facilitate collaboration and save vital tax dollars.
Many states with design-build laws also allow public contracting agencies to utilize other methods which encourage integrated practices and teamwork among project partners. In 2003 Massachusetts created a special commission on construction reform. The commission, which included all major stakeholders, crafted legislation that was signed into law in 2004 and has successfully allowed public agencies to utilize various project delivery methods based on the unique requirements of each individual project.
A recent study of more than 200 capital facility projects conducted by researchers at Pennsylvania State University found that project-delivery methods alone do not determine success. This study, Maximizing Success in Integrated Projects, concluded that project success was dependent on the access to various delivery methods, which could be aligned with a comprehensive delivery strategy to meet the needs of a specific project. The American Institute of Architects, New York State supports the conclusions of this study. It confirms the need to implement industrywide adoption of approaches to project delivery that promote early and consistent involvement of public owners, architects, engineers, constructors and end users in an environment of trust, fair compensation, clearly defined goals and transparency.
Design-build is one of many project delivery methods which can address 21st-century design and construction needs. However, it would be unwise to rely on design-build as the ultimate solution to rehabilitating and reimagining our built environment.
Certain public authorities, such as the Dormitory Authority of New York State, have limited authority to choose from a wider range of project delivery methods that include but are not limited to design-build. These alternative methods have been successfully incorporated into its project management and utilized in the delivery of student housing.
New York state needs comprehensive legislation that gives all public contracting agencies greater flexibility to deliver projects efficiently and cost-effectively.
Kirk Narburgh, AIA, is the president of the American Institute of Architects, New York State and CEO/managing partner at King + King Architects in Syracuse. Georgi Ann Bailey is the executive director of the American Institute of Architects New York State.
This article appeared in Crain’s New York Business. Entire contents © 2018 Crain Communications Inc.
Issue: 2018, Vol. 1: Economic Development
2017 Fall Quarterly
2017 Summer Quarterly
The American Institute of Architects New York State (AIANYS) is announcing the recipient of the 2017 AIANYS Firm of the Year Award.
Established in 2005, the purpose of the Firm Award is to recognize notable achievements in design, community service, education and service to the profession and the AIA by an architectural firm within New York State.
This year’s recipient is nARCHITECTS, Brooklyn, NY. Principals Eric Bunge, AIA, and Mimi Hoang, AIA, founded nARCHITECTS in 1999 with the aim of joining innovative concepts, social responsibility and technical precision in addressing contemporary issues. As a small practice operating internationally, inspiration and purpose are found in the uniqueness of local contexts.
AIANYS President Robert E. Stark, AIA, said, “I congratulate Eric and Mimi, and the whole nARCHITECTS team on receiving this prestigious award. nARCHITECTS’ innovative approach on design makes them stand out in a time where there are so many amazing firms. Noted for their projects around the metro New York area and worldwide, their projects are distinguished in cities on the forefront of design. Their ability to incorporate technology with a multipurpose structure, using cost effective and sustainable means, melds these projects in chorus with the surrounding cityscape. The nARCHITECTS team demonstrates their commitment to the profession, and I again congratulate the entire team.”
nARCHITECTS responded to the award, “We are thrilled to be recognized by AIANYS and proud to contribute to the creative energy of our state. This award is particularly meaningful for us in its broad emphasis on professional, civic and academic contributions, all of which continue to inspire our design thinking.”
AIANYS Executive Director Georgi Bailey, said “nARCHITECTS’ commitment to the profession is notable among of the many prolific architectural firms in New York State. The team has proven through their innovative design approach that they are a leader in the profession, noted by their peers and capturing the attention of the design world. I would like to congratulate Eric, Mimi and the nARCHITECTS team on behalf of all AIA New York State members.”
The recipients are going to be honored at a reception held on the evening of Friday, November 10th, 2017 in Albany, NY.
The American Institute of Architects New York State (AIANYS) is announcing the recipients of the 2017 AIANYS Design Awards.
Annually since 1968, the Design Awards has celebrated, honored and promoted excellence in architectural design and planning by New York State architects.
These awe-inspiring structures are not only beautiful, but are built with purpose. Whether it is for housing, retail or business, a building is a canvas and architects create masterpieces while accounting for preservation, resiliency, energy efficiency and sustainability. New York has established itself as a global hub for architecture, and these awards honor some of the best projects.
AIANYS President Robert E. Stark, AIA, said, “Demonstrative of what we have come to expect in New York, these buildings are simply amazing. These structures are an investment in the built environment and add value to the communities they serve. Modern to traditional, preservation to unbuilt, they are remarkable in their own right. I would like to acknowledge all who submitted their projects and congratulate the recipients of these prestigious awards.”
AIANYS Executive Director Georgi Ann Bailey said, “New York architects are universally praised for their design excellence and these projects are no different. Our residents and visitors are the real winners; they are the people who live, work, play and stay in these works of art.”
The recipients will be honored at a reception held on the evening of November 10thth, 2017 in Albany, NY.
Announcement addressing the United States withdrawal from the Paris Accord
In the wake of yesterday’s announcement addressing the United States withdrawal from the Paris Accord, I would like to reaffirm AIA New York State’s commitment to creating a sustainable world.
Architects inherently look to design in an environmentally sensitive way as we strive to mitigate climate change through responsible design and construction practices. Architects, especially New York State architects, have been at the forefront of sustainable design as we build for the future of not only New York, but the U.S. and the world.
New York State is the epicenter of progressive design and our member architects are implementing innovative sustainable design worldwide. We are global leaders by example, domestic leaders by design and community leaders by nature.
I would like to echo the Institute’s President Thomas Vonier, FAIA, in, “The AIA will not retreat from its long-established efforts to conserve energy and to deploy renewable resources in buildings. We will continue to lead in efforts to curb the use of fuels and technologies that needlessly pollute our atmosphere and harm our environment. This makes good sense economically, and it is in the best interests of those we serve: our clients and the public.”
We will continue to design our buildings and communities responsibly, accounting for our environment, and we will remain stewards and leaders for a green and sustainable planet.
Robert E. Stark, AIA
2017 AIANYS President
2017 Winter Quarterly: Infrastructure
The American Institute of Architects New York State (AIANYS) Announces Support of the Emergency Responder Act
For Immediate Release:
Contact: Nick Isaacs, 518-449-3334, email@example.com
The American Institute of Architects New York State (AIANYS) and its partner organizations in the design and construction industry are calling on the Legislature to pass the Emergency Responder Act during the 2017 Legislative Session.
A press conference featuring the bill’s legislative sponsors and industry supporters was be held on Monday, February 6th at 12:15PM in the LCA room of the Legislative Office Building in Albany, NY.
During and after a catastrophic event, architectural, engineering and construction expertise is needed to assess the integrity of buildings, infrastructure and their engineered systems, to provide advice on how to best stabilize, repair and rehabilitate the damaged structures. The Emergency Responder Act would enact legislation allowing licensed design professionals and others in the building and construction industry certain rights and benefits to provide advice, professional services, labor, and materials during a declared emergency.
AIANYS President Robert E. Stark, AIA, said, “Enactment of this legislation would allow architects and other industry professionals to do what we do best, help the general public. During emergency situations, member architects want to help by using our expertise in assessing structural issues which may have occurred during the event. As architects, we are trained to use design thinking to address various issues. We want to use our expertise to help in these situations.”
Handcuffing practicing design professionals in these situations is an issue of liability, where private individuals and firms within the construction industry face liability exposure when lending services to assist various levels of government during and after a disaster.
Stark continued, “Government employees are provided with liability protections for response and recovery work. Extending this to private professionals who want to help in emergency situations would provide expanded response capacity critical situations. In times of great need, government entities should be able to call on the design and construction industry, expanding their assessment capabilities, to help protect and by a preserve the health, safety and welfare of those New Yorkers impacted by a disaster.”
Disasters on scale with hurricanes Irene or Sandy require thousands of life-safety inspections of structures, infrastructure and public spaces. Allowing government entities to mobilize private sector practitioners in an expeditious manner with proper protections, response and recovery times will decrease and the public will be better protected from dangers borne in the aftermath of catastrophic events. AIA New York State and its partner organizations are committed to ensuring that communities are prepared for future disasters. Extending certain rights and benefits to licensed design professionals and others in the building and construction industry during and immediately after a declared emergency will greatly enhance response and recovery efforts.
Nicole Schuster, AIA, President of AIACNY, wrote an op-ed explaining the AIACNY’s stance on a major redevelopment project in Syracuse which was widely received in the local media. This project may be viewed as a model for elevated viaduct redevelopment nationwide. The article was republished in print format and included in the Sunday edition of the Post Standard, has been shared over 450 times and has numerous comments. To post your comment or share, click here.
From Syrcause.com and The Post-Standard
Architects: We need big ideas, not a bigger Interstate 81 (Your letters)
This image from Rethink81 shows what Almond Street might look like without the Interstate 81 viaduct. The CNY Chapter of the American Institute of Architects supports demolition of the highway in favor of a Community Grid plan that would bring life and commerce into spaces now in the shadow of the interstate. (Rethink81)
To the Editor:
Close your eyes and visualize a mini Park Avenue in New York City, or Millennium Park in Chicago. These urban areas are pedestrian-friendly spaces with a mix of high-rises and street-level mixed-use properties. These locations, home to some of the most valuable real estate in the world, are also critical components of a city street grid.
The I-81 Viaduct Project is an opportunity for our region to think big. Not a big new highway, but grand and innovative ideas on what to do with the (hopefully) soon-to-be former viaduct corridor.
Selecting the Community Grid option over replacing the current Viaduct with a newer, bigger highway should be a “no-brainer.” Removing the elevated highway will open up a range of opportunities for our region; to further reinvigorate the city, to reconnect divided communities and to stimulate unprecedented growth.
Syracuse was one of many cities across the country which made the fateful urban planning decision in the 1950s and 1960s to build elevated highways through their urban centers. In every case, the neighborhoods in the shadows of the viaducts suffered a similar fate; abandonment and isolation, reduced property values, pollution and noise. Beyond the socio-economic impacts on neighborhoods, city highways severely limit economic development, and they are not terribly efficient, either. Have you ever been one of the 44,000 people a day who use Exit 18 (Harrison/Adams) during the morning and evening commute?
Today, cities like San Francisco, New Orleans, Boston, Dallas and New Haven have already, or are in the process of, tearing down elevated city highways. In Milwaukee, where the Park East Freeway was razed in 1999, urban development has flourished with property values in the affected area increasing by 45 percent. In 2007, Manpower relocated its 900-employee global headquarters to a site in downtown Milwaukee formerly occupied by elevated the highway.
This can happen in Syracuse.
We have an opportunity to revitalize the valuable areas currently shadowed by I-81.
The economics favor the Community Grid option as well. The Grid costs $400 million less than the Viaduct, which also takes longer to build and requires increasing annual maintenance costs over the next 50-plus years. Equally important, the Community Grid stimulates economic growth. There is a need to re-densify the city, especially in walkable areas like those around Almond Avenue. Walkable zones attract people and development generating sales and property tax revenue. We have an opportunity to revitalize the valuable areas currently shadowed by I-81.
In addition to the community-building and economic development benefits, there are compelling logistics arguments for the Community Grid. Eighty-eight percent of the traffic on the existing viaduct consists of people travelling to the city – most for work. The current highway, however, is designed to help cars bypass the city altogether.
The Community Grid design taps into the existing infrastructure, dispersing traffic throughout the city grid by promoting broader use of the existing underutilized street network. The design provides direct connections to key destinations in the city and adds new exits to ease congestion and further spread traffic. In the grid, instead of one path to their destination, drivers will have multiple access points.
The grid design is also the least disruptive option, requiring the acquisition of just five buildings. The construction of a new Viaduct will condemn and demolish 24 buildings, including at least 12 structures of historical significance.
The American Institute of Architects Central New York chapter created the AIACNY81 Task Force in 2013 to carefully follow this process; to help broaden community knowledge and promote good design and planning practices. Based on our review of the current plans, we strongly recommend the Community Grid alternative, which would knit the city together again and offer unprecedented redevelopment potential.
For this process to be truly successful we must view this as more than just fixing a mistake, or designing a better traffic pattern. The Community Grid presents an urban development opportunity which will have a profound effect on our region for generations.
Syracuse, Central New York and New York state must maximize this opportunity. Let’s get this right with big ideas not a big new highway. We look forward to being an integral part of this important planning conversation.
AIA, LEED AP BD+C, CPHC
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
AIA New York State
Phone: (518) 449-3334
The American Institute of Architects New York State Announces the Firm of the Year: WXY architecture + urban design
Albany, NY – The American Institute of Architects New York State (AIANYS) is announcing the recipient of the 2016 AIANYS Firm of the Year Award. Established in 2005, the purpose of the Firm Award is to recognize notable achievements in design, community service, education and service to the profession and the AIA by an architectural firm within New York State.
WXY architecture + urban design, from New York City, is an award winning firm specializing in architecture, urban design and planning. WXY founders and AIANYS members Claire Weisz, FAIA and Mark Yoes, AIA, and Principals Layng Pew, AIA, and Dr. Adam Lubinsky, PhD, AICP, have guided the firm to be recognized as an innovative leader in architecture, urban resiliency and public space design, noted for their progressive and thoughtful approach to sustainable design, melding the design with client and community engagement.
The WXY team believes in responsible design, taking a thoughtful and innovative approach integrating the many aspects of large scale projects, such as infrastructure and economic development, to envision reimagined urban design, cityscapes and revitalized spaces to enhance our communities.
AIANYS President Margaret O’Donoghue Castillo, FAIA, said, “I congratulate Claire and Mark and their team on receiving this award and cannot think of a more deserving firm. WXY have been the innovative leaders on sustainable urbanism, noted for their projects around the great city of New York and also in Detroit, Texas and beyond. Their ability to create structures and plans which are in chorus with the surrounding cityscape, and do so with environmentally sensible means, demonstrate their commitment to the profession. They embody what being part of AIA is all about. Congratulations to the entire WXY team.”
“Building this firm has been an amazing collaboration,” said Claire Weisz. “But the real reward is being a part of so many transformational projects around New York. It’s truly humbling to know we have been a part of making New York a more vibrant and livable place, and for this work to be so highly regarded by AIANYS.” said Mark Yoes.
“This award confirms for us that the future of architecture is multi-disciplinary.” said Layng Pew. Adam Lubinsky adds “The world has become too complex for these disciplines to exist apart from each other. We’ve seen at WXY that transformational change—such as the rebuilding of the Rockaway Boardwalk after Hurricane Sandy, or designing a new process for community engagement in East Harlem—can only happen when planning informs the spatial relationships of the built environment.”
AIANYS Executive Director Georgi Bailey, said “WXY’s commitment to the profession is a highlight of the many prolific architectural firms in New York State. The team at WXY have proven they are an innovative leader in the profession, noted by their peers and capturing the attention of the design world. I would like to congratulate Claire, Mark and the WXY team on behalf of all AIA New York State members.”
The recipients will be honored at a reception held on the evening of Friday, September 30th, 2016 in Saratoga Springs, NY.
AIANYS is the state component of the American Institute of Architects and is composed of 13 components representing over 8,500 architecture professionals statewide. For further information, please visit www.aianys.org or call (518)-449-3334.
Documents and/or Photos available for this release:
Seaglass Carousel by Wade Zimmerman
To view supporting documents and/or photos, go to www.enr-corp.com/pressroom and enter Release ID: 404730
Architecture in the Age of Digital Imagery
The AEC industry is poised to take on virtual reality and augmented reality as a critical component of the professional toolbox.
There are two related emerging, or more appropriately re-emerging, methods of visualization which hold a promise to change the way architectural design and construction are viewed by the designer, builder, client and general public. Virtual Reality (VR) and Augmented Reality (AR) are three dimensional computational visualizations that rely on real-time user interaction with digital models and data. Current computational machinery, particularly portable technology, such as smart phones with increased processing power and ubiquitous nature of the equipment, coupled with high-definition screens, advanced software, GPS systems and other technologies, has rendered VR/AR at the point of public consumption, providing for a resurgence of use the AEC industry is perfectly poised to take advantage of.
2016 AIANYS Design Awards Recipients Announced
The American Institute of Architects New York State (AIANYS) is announcing the recipients of the 2016 AIANYS Design Awards. Annually since 1968, the Design Awards has celebrated, honored and promoted excellence in architectural design and planning by New York State architects.
“Architects, as the leaders in design of the built environment, are responsible to act as stewards of the Earth.” – The American Institute of Architects
Currently, the federal government is moving to implement the Clean Power Plan with a goal of reducing carbon dioxide emissions by 32 percent. The EPA will require every state to come up with an approved implementation plan to meet these targets. While carbon reduction goals vary from state to state, New York has been a leader on the national stage when it comes to policies aimed at reducing carbon emissions, including the Regional Green House Initiative (RGGI) and the newly proposed goal to require 50 percent of the energy portfolio to come from renewable sources.
According to the National Science and Technology Council, commercial and residential buildings consume a third of the world’s energy and account for 40 percent of U.S. carbon emissions. If worldwide energy-use trends continue, buildings will become the largest consumer of global energy by 2025—more than the transportation and industrial sectors combined. The domestic energy and climate change challenge cannot be addressed without changing the way our buildings are designed, constructed, and operated.
Architects are uniquely positioned in leading efforts to increase energy efficiency in the commercial building market through their work as creative commercial building problem solvers. From establishing the project mass and orientation to incorporating passive lighting and ventilation strategies, architects hold the key to reducing energy consumption of building designs.
Current trends in consumer demand for environmentally responsible buildings and products show high-performing building design will be a lasting theme in the construction industry. To meet this demand, the AIA has embarked on an ambitious 2030 Commitment to quantify and report the progress of AIA members to reduce greenhouse gas emissions in the built environment and ultimately reverse the trend of carbon output.
Through a partnership with the U.S. Department of Energy, the AIA developed the AIA 2030 Design Data Exchange, or DDx. This tool streamlines the process for firms to share project information in real time so other architects can view their building performance projections and measure them against their goals.
For 150 years, AIA members have been advancing the quality of life through innovations to the built environment. Architects have moved to the forefront of the 2030 Challenge by designing “net zero” buildings, where the amount of energy the building consumes is equivalent to the amount of energy produced. Further, there are more and more instances where architects are designing net positive buildings, to actually contribute more resources than used to operate. AIA members across the country have reported a 270% increase in net zero projects, indicative of the trend for efficient design. In beauty and function, all architecture is beginning to resemble energy efficient architecture.
Part of the commitment is also to design resilient buildings. In response to Superstorm Sandy, Hurricane Irene, and Tropical Storm Lee, architects have been working with the NY Rising Community Reconstruction Program to mitigate the extreme effects of climate change.
Leading by Design: This is the architect’s contribution to the creation of a sustainable world.
For more information on how architecture affects you, contact AIA New York State at 518-449-3334 or visit www.aianys.org.
The American Institute of Architects New York State (AIANYS) is announcing the recipient of the…